Criminal defence

Magistrates' court or Crown Court: where a case is heard and what to expect

Summary offences go to the magistrates' court, indictable-only to the Crown Court. Either-way offences can go to either; in November 2026 adults could still elect a jury.

Last reviewed 8 min read Solicitors Guide editorial team

On this page
  1. Key facts
  2. The three types of offence
  3. What the magistrates' court can sentence
  4. Your right to choose a Crown Court trial
  5. Proposed changes in the Courts and Tribunals Bill
  6. Short sentences and the suspended sentence presumption
  7. Legal aid in each court
  8. Motoring cases in the magistrates' court
  9. When to get a criminal defence solicitor and how to choose one
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Sources

The type of offence decides where a criminal case is heard in England and Wales. Summary offences are dealt with in the magistrates' court, indictable-only offences go to the Crown Court, and either-way offences can be heard in either. When we checked on 16 November 2026, an adult defendant facing trial for an either-way offence could still choose a Crown Court trial.

The magistrates' court can impose up to 6 months in custody for each summary offence and up to 12 months for each either-way offence. A bill before Parliament would remove the right to choose a Crown Court trial for either-way offences. When we checked on 16 November 2026, the bill was in the House of Lords at committee stage and was still not law.

Key facts

  • Summary offences: magistrates' court, up to 6 months in custody per offence.
  • Either-way offences: magistrates' court or Crown Court, up to 12 months per offence in the magistrates' court.
  • Indictable-only offences: Crown Court.
  • The 12-month limit for either-way offences has applied since 18 November 2024.
  • When we checked on 16 November 2026, the law still allowed an adult defendant facing trial for an either-way offence to elect a Crown Court trial with a jury.
  • The Courts and Tribunals Bill would end that right. It was still before Parliament on 16 November 2026.
  • Since 22 March 2026, custodial sentences of 12 months or less are presumed to be suspended unless there are exceptional circumstances.

The three types of offence

Every criminal offence falls into one of three groups, and the group decides which court can hear the case. Your charge sheet or court papers will name the offence, and a solicitor can tell you which group it is in.

Type of offence Where it is heard Magistrates' court custody limit
Summary Magistrates' court 6 months per offence
Either-way Magistrates' court or Crown Court. When we checked on 16 November 2026, an adult defendant could still elect a Crown Court trial. 12 months per offence
Indictable-only Crown Court Does not apply

The custody limits in this table come from section 224 of the Sentencing Act 2020. They cap what the magistrates' court can do and do not apply in the Crown Court.

What the magistrates' court can sentence

For a summary offence, the magistrates' court can impose up to 6 months in custody per offence. For an either-way offence, the limit is 12 months per offence.

The 12-month limit for either-way offences has applied since 18 November 2024, under a statutory instrument (SI 2024/1067). Articles written before then may describe the magistrates' powers differently, so check the date on anything you read.

These are maximums. Any sentence depends on the offence and the circumstances. Once a solicitor has seen the evidence, they can explain the likely range for your charge.

Your right to choose a Crown Court trial

If you are charged with an either-way offence, you can elect to be tried in the Crown Court, where a jury decides the case. When we checked on 16 November 2026, that remained the law for the ordinary adult either-way trial procedure. The Courts and Tribunals Bill would remove this right, as explained below, but the right remains until the bill becomes law and the change is brought into force. Check GOV.UK for the latest position.

It is a big decision, so make it with legal advice. Your solicitor is likely to raise points like these:

  • Who decides the case. A Crown Court trial is in front of a jury. A magistrates' court trial is not.
  • Sentencing limits. The 6-month and 12-month caps apply only in the magistrates' court.
  • Legal aid. A Crown Court trial passes the interests of justice test for legal aid automatically, but the Crown Court has its own means test, which can involve paying a contribution.
  • Short sentences. Since 22 March 2026, custodial sentences of 12 months or less are presumed to be suspended unless there are exceptional circumstances.

Do not decide on the basis of what happened to someone else. Every case turns on its own evidence, and the right choice for one defendant can be the wrong one for another.

Proposed changes in the Courts and Tribunals Bill

When we checked on 16 November 2026, none of the changes below had become law, and the bill was still being considered in the House of Lords. Check GOV.UK for its progress. The government introduced the Courts and Tribunals Bill in February 2026.

The bill would:

  • remove the right to elect a Crown Court trial for all either-way offences
  • allow later regulations to raise the magistrates' sentencing powers for either-way offences to 18 or 24 months
  • allow trials by a judge alone, without a jury, for certain long and complex fraud cases

The government has dropped an earlier proposal for a Crown Court Bench Division, which would have meant judge-only trials for less serious cases.

If you have been charged with an either-way offence, ask your solicitor to confirm the current position before you decide. It could change while your case is going on.

Short sentences and the suspended sentence presumption

Section 1 of the Sentencing Act 2026 creates a presumption that a custodial sentence of 12 months or less will be suspended, unless there are exceptional circumstances. Its record on legislation.gov.uk gives 22 March 2026 as the date it came into force.

New release provisions in the Sentencing Act 2026 are being phased in from 1 October 2026 under SI 2026/953. When we checked on 16 November 2026, another release stage had started on 10 November, with further stages due through 8 June 2027 and a separate start date of 12 October 2027 for certain people already released on a curfew licence. Check GOV.UK for which stages have started. If you or a relative face a custodial sentence, ask a solicitor how the new rules affect you.

Legal aid for representation in court depends on two tests: a merits test, called the interests of justice test, and a means test. You pass the means test automatically if you are under 18 or receive Universal Credit, Income Support, income-based Jobseeker's Allowance, income-based ESA or Pension Guarantee Credit. Advice at the police station is different. It is free for anyone questioned, whatever their means.

The means test takes your household gross income and adjusts it for family size. As at November 2026, adjusted income of £12,475 or less is funded. Above £12,475 but below £22,325, you need a full means test. At £22,325 or more, you are not funded in the magistrates' court.

You also have to pass the interests of justice test. You may pass if, for example, you are likely to lose your liberty or your livelihood, or to suffer serious damage to your reputation, or if the case involves a substantial question of law.

A Crown Court trial passes the interests of justice test automatically, as do committals for sentence, retrials and voluntary bills. On means, you are not eligible if your household disposable income is £37,500 or more. With disposable income over £3,398 and under £37,500, legal aid is granted but you pay an income contribution. If you have £30,000 or more in capital and equity, a capital contribution may be due if you are convicted. You can ask for a hardship review.

Our guide to criminal legal aid covers both tests in more detail.

Motoring cases in the magistrates' court

Some road traffic offences are summary-only, so they are dealt with in the magistrates' court. Firms that advertise magistrates' court representation for summary-only road traffic offences dealt with at a single hearing must publish their prices under the SRA Transparency Rules. Publicly funded work is excluded from this rule.

That makes it easier to compare costs for a driving case. Browse motoring offence solicitors, or read our guides to drink driving penalties and speeding fines and points.

When to get a criminal defence solicitor and how to choose one

Get advice as early as you can, ideally at the police station, where it is free. If you are charged, a solicitor can tell you what type of offence you face, which court will hear it, whether you have a choice of court and whether you qualify for legal aid. If you can choose a Crown Court trial, talk it through with them before you decide.

When you compare criminal defence solicitors:

  • Check regulation. Find the firm's SRA number and confirm it on the Solicitors Regulation Authority's register before you instruct it.
  • Ask about legal aid. If you may qualify, ask whether the firm does criminal legal aid work in the court your case is in.
  • Get fees in writing. If you are paying privately, ask for a written quote that says what is covered, whether VAT is included and what happens if the case goes to trial. Our legal fees page explains how solicitors charge.
  • Ask about experience in the court your case will be heard in, and who will represent you at each hearing.
  • Ask about language. If you would rather discuss your case in another language, ask whether a solicitor can advise you in it.

Firms on Solicitors Guide are ordered by GuideScore, which comes only from checked client reviews, and firms with no reviews yet are listed A to Z. A featured firm is shown first, with a "Featured" badge.

Courts and legal aid work differently in Scotland and in Northern Ireland, so this guide applies to England and Wales only. It is general information as at November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the magistrates' court and the Crown Court?

Summary offences are dealt with in the magistrates' court and indictable-only offences go to the Crown Court. Either-way offences can be heard in either court. The magistrates' court can impose up to 6 months in custody per summary offence and 12 months per either-way offence. Crown Court trials are decided by a jury, and those sentencing limits do not apply there.

Can I choose to have my case heard in the Crown Court?

When we checked on 16 November 2026, yes: an adult defendant facing trial for an either-way offence could still choose a Crown Court trial, which is decided by a jury. The Courts and Tribunals Bill would remove this right for all either-way offences, but it was still in the House of Lords and was not law. Check GOV.UK and take legal advice before you decide.

What is the maximum sentence a magistrates' court can give?

Up to 6 months in custody for each summary offence and up to 12 months for each either-way offence, as at November 2026. The 12-month limit has applied since 18 November 2024. When we checked on 16 November 2026, the Courts and Tribunals Bill was not law; it would allow later regulations to raise magistrates' sentencing powers for either-way offences to 18 or 24 months.

Is the right to jury trial being abolished?

When we checked on 16 November 2026, the proposed restrictions on jury trials had not become law. The Courts and Tribunals Bill, introduced in February 2026, would remove the right to elect a Crown Court trial for either-way offences and allow judge-alone trials in certain long and complex fraud cases. It was still being considered in the House of Lords and could be amended. The government had dropped the proposed Crown Court Bench Division. Check GOV.UK for the bill's progress.

Can I get legal aid in the Crown Court?

Yes, if your means qualify. A Crown Court trial passes the interests of justice test automatically, so the means test decides it. You are not eligible if your household disposable income is £37,500 or more. Over £3,398 and under £37,500, you get legal aid but pay an income contribution. With £30,000 or more in capital and equity, a capital contribution may be due after conviction.

Sources

  1. Sentencing Act 2020, section 224 legislation.gov.uk
  2. SI 2024/1067: magistrates' court sentencing powers legislation.gov.uk
  3. Ministry of Justice: Government response to the Independent Review of the Criminal Courts gov.uk
  4. Sentencing Act 2026, section 1 legislation.gov.uk
  5. SI 2026/953 (Sentencing Act 2026 commencement) legislation.gov.uk
  6. Legal Aid Agency: Work out who qualifies for criminal legal aid gov.uk
  7. Legal Aid Agency: Criminal legal aid means testing gov.uk
  8. SRA: Transparency Rules sra.org.uk
  9. GOV.UK: Being arrested, your rights gov.uk
  10. Ministry of Justice: Courts and Tribunals Bill factsheet gov.uk

General information, not legal advice

This guide explains the law in England and Wales in general terms. Every situation is different, so speak to a qualified solicitor before you act. You can compare solicitors here.

Last reviewed . Written by the Solicitors Guide editorial team under our editorial policy.