Solicitor reviews only help you choose if they are genuine. This policy explains who can leave a review on Solicitors Guide, what we publish and reject, how we check reviews, and how firms can reply to or challenge them. It covers reviews of firms and of individual solicitors. The same rules apply to every firm, including our featured partner firm, Prime Legal Solicitors.
Who can review a firm
You can review a firm if you are, or were, its client. That includes a first consultation where the firm gave you advice. To leave a review, you must:
- be 18 or over
- sign in to an account with a confirmed email address
- leave only one review of the firm for each matter it handled for you
- confirm that you are a genuine client, that you do not work for the firm and that you were not the other side in your case
If the firm later helps you with a new matter, you can review that separately. We never show your email address.
Who cannot leave a review
- Anyone who works for the firm or has worked there, and their close family and friends.
- The other side in a case the firm handled, and anyone acting for them. If a firm acted for your ex-partner, you were not its client.
- Other law firms and their staff, and anyone acting for a competitor.
- Anyone paid or offered anything to write a review, such as a discount, a gift, a refund or a prize draw entry.
- Anyone writing about someone else's experience.
What we publish
- Honest accounts of your own experience with the firm or solicitor, positive or negative.
- An overall rating from 1 to 5 stars. You can also rate initial impressions, legal knowledge, value for money, approachability, documentation accuracy and communication. These extra ratings appear on the profile but do not count towards the firm's GuideScore.
- Your first name and the initial of your surname, for example Sam T.
- The practice area, if you choose one, and the date of your review.
- The firm's reply, if it posts one.
We may ask when the firm acted for you. We use your answer to check your review, and we do not publish it.
We publish critical reviews on the same terms as positive ones. We do not hide a review because a firm dislikes it, and no firm can pay to have a review removed or pushed down the page.
What "Verified client" means
Every published review carries a "Verified client" label. It means the reviewer signed in with a confirmed email address, confirmed that they were a client of the firm and not an employee or the other side, and passed our checks. We do not see documents for every review. We ask for evidence when our checks raise a concern or a firm challenges a review.
What we reject
- Fake reviews, and reviews by anyone who was not a client.
- Reviews that were paid for, rewarded or written in return for anything.
- Reviews by anyone with a conflict of interest, as listed above.
- Reviews about something other than the firm's service, such as the other side or the law itself.
- Personal details, such as phone numbers, email addresses, home addresses and case reference numbers. Do not name other people involved in your case, such as your ex-partner or the other side. You can name the solicitor or staff who acted for you.
- Anything that could identify a child involved in family court proceedings, such as their name, school or address, or details of a private family court hearing about children. Publishing this can be a criminal offence or contempt of court under section 97 of the Children Act 1989 and section 12 of the Administration of Justice Act 1960.
- Allegations of crime, dishonesty or professional misconduct stated as fact. If you think a solicitor has acted dishonestly or broken the SRA's rules, report it to the SRA.
- Offensive, discriminatory or threatening language.
- Adverts, links and reviews posted more than once.
We do not edit reviews. If a review breaks a rule, we reject it and record the reason. If you ask, we will tell you why, and you can send us a new version.
How we check solicitor reviews
- A member of our team reads every review before it is published.
- Automated checks flag patterns that suggest fake reviews: the same text posted twice, one person reviewing several firms in a short time, or a sudden burst of reviews for one firm. A person makes the final decision.
- We may ask you for evidence that you were a client, such as a letter or invoice from the firm. You can black out anything you do not want us to see. We do not share your evidence with the firm unless you agree.
- We keep a record of every decision and the reason for it.
Right of reply for firms
A firm that has claimed its profile can post one public reply to each review. The reply appears under the review, in the firm's name. Only the firm can post a reply in its name.
- Replies must be polite and relevant.
- Solicitors must keep client matters confidential. A reply must not reveal details of the client's case, even if the review mentions them.
- We may remove a reply that breaks these rules.
How a firm can challenge a review
A firm can challenge a review if:
- the reviewer was never a client, and the firm can show evidence
- the review is factually inaccurate
- the review is offensive or defamatory
- the reviewer has a conflict of interest
Not recognising the reviewer's name is not enough, because we show only a first name and initial. While we investigate, the review is hidden and does not count towards the firm's GuideScore. We may ask the firm and the reviewer for information.
- If we uphold the challenge, we remove the review and block further reviews from that reviewer.
- If we reject the challenge, the review goes back up.
- If we have not decided within 14 days, the review goes back up automatically.
How to report a review
Anyone can report a review that breaks this policy. Email hello@solicitorsguide.co.uk with "Report a review" in the subject line, and include:
- the link to the firm's profile
- the reviewer's name and the date of the review
- the rule you think it breaks, and why
Changing or removing your own review
Email us from the address you used to post your review.
- To change it, send us the new version. We check it under this policy and then replace the old one.
- To remove it, tell us which review it is and we will take it down.
Takedown requests
If you believe a review is unlawful, for example because it is defamatory, invades your privacy or breaks a court order, email us with "Legal request" in the subject line. Include:
- your name and how we can contact you
- the link to the review and the exact words you object to
- why you believe they are unlawful, and which statements you say are untrue
- a copy of any court order
We may hide the review while we consider your request. We usually tell the reviewer about the complaint and give them a chance to respond, unless the law prevents this. We will tell you what we decide, and we comply with court orders. We do not remove a review because it is critical.
Inviting clients to review your firm
Firms can invite clients to leave a review on Solicitors Guide, as long as they:
- do not invite only the clients they expect to be happy
- do not offer anything in return, whatever the rating
- do not write, edit or post reviews for clients, or put clients under pressure
Fake reviews and reviews that hide an incentive are banned under Schedule 20 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024. If we find that a firm has broken these rules, we may remove the reviews affected.
Changes to this policy
We will update this page if our rules change. The date at the top of the page shows when we last changed it.