We list firms in order of their GuideScore, which comes only from client reviews on Solicitors Guide that have passed our checks. That is how we rank firms, with one exception: a firm that pays for a featured placement is shown first, with a "Featured" label. Paying never changes any firm's GuideScore or the order of the other firms.
The order on every listing
- Featured firm. If a featured firm covers the practice area and town you are looking at, it appears first, labelled "Featured". It is never given a rank number.
- All other firms, by GuideScore. The highest GuideScore comes first.
- Ties, in alphabetical order. Firms with the same GuideScore are listed A to Z by name.
Apart from the featured placement, no firm can pay to move up the list. Claiming a profile does not change a firm's position either.
How we rank firms: the GuideScore
A simple average can mislead. A firm with 3 five-star reviews would beat a firm with 80 reviews averaging 4.8 stars, even though the second firm has a far longer record. The GuideScore deals with this by blending each firm's average rating with the average rating across the whole site.
GuideScore = (n × R + 15 × C) ÷ (n + 15)
- n is the number of published reviews the firm has on Solicitors Guide.
- R is the firm's average rating from those reviews, between 1 and 5 stars.
- C is the average rating of all published reviews on the site, across every firm.
- 15 is the weight. It works like a starting balance of 15 reviews at the site-wide average.
Each new review moves a firm's GuideScore away from the site-wide average and towards its own record. At 15 reviews, the firm's own rating makes up half of its GuideScore. At 45 reviews, it makes up three quarters. A few five-star reviews lift a GuideScore only a little. To rise well above the average, a firm needs many good reviews.
Worked example
These figures are made up to show how the formula works. Imagine the average rating across the site is 4.5 stars.
| Firm | Reviews | Average rating | GuideScore | Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Firm A | 80 | 4.8 | 4.75 | 1st |
| Firm B | 4 | 5.0 | 4.61 | 2nd |
| Firm C | 0 | No reviews yet | 4.50 | 3rd |
| Firm D | 20 | 4.2 | 4.33 | 4th |
Firm B has a 5.0 average, but from only 4 reviews, so it sits below Firm A. Firm D's reviews are below the site-wide average, so it sits below Firm C, which has no reviews yet.
A firm's profile shows its average rating and the number of reviews behind it. The GuideScore decides the order on listings.
What the GuideScore leaves out
The GuideScore uses the overall star ratings in published client reviews on Solicitors Guide, and nothing else. It does not use:
- payments of any kind, including for a featured placement
- ratings from Google or other review sites, even where a profile shows them
- whether a firm has claimed its profile or replied to reviews
- the optional ratings for initial impressions, legal knowledge, value for money, approachability, documentation accuracy and communication
Those optional ratings appear on firm profiles to help you compare. We recalculate a firm's GuideScore when one of its reviews is published or removed, and we recalculate every firm's GuideScore daily so the site-wide average stays current.
Which reviews count
Only published reviews count. Under our reviews policy, we publish a review only if:
- it comes from a client or former client of the firm
- it is the client's only review of that firm for that matter
- the reviewer has confirmed their email address
- a member of our team has checked it
Firms can post one public reply to each review. Replies do not affect the score. If a firm challenges a review, we hide it while we investigate, and it does not count towards the GuideScore. If we have not decided within 14 days, the review goes back up and counts again.
Firms with no reviews yet
Many firms do not have any reviews on Solicitors Guide yet. Their profiles and cards say "No reviews yet", with a link to write the first one.
- While no firm on the site has a published review, every firm has the same GuideScore. Firms are then listed alphabetically, after any featured firm.
- Once other firms have reviews, a firm with none is treated as average. Its GuideScore equals the site-wide average, so it sits below firms whose reviews lift them above the average, and above firms whose reviews put them below it.
A firm's position without reviews says nothing about the quality of its work. Check its SRA record and speak to the firm before you decide.
Which firms appear on a page
- Practice areas. A firm appears under a practice area, such as divorce, when its website, its SRA record or the firm itself tells us it does that work. A broad area, such as family law, also includes firms listed under its specialist areas.
- Towns and regions. A town page lists firms with an office in that town. A region page, such as Greater Manchester, lists firms with an office anywhere in the region.
- Firms that advise online. Some firms advise clients anywhere in England and Wales by phone or video. They can appear on town pages where they have no office. They are ranked in the same way, and their card says they advise online.
We list only firms authorised by the SRA, and we do not list every firm in England and Wales yet.
Featured placements
A featured placement is a paid listing. Prime Legal Solicitors is currently the featured firm on Solicitors Guide, and we have a commercial relationship with it.
- Paid. The featured firm pays us for its placement.
- Labelled. Wherever we promote it, it carries a "Featured" label with a link to this section.
- Shown first, where relevant. It appears at the top of listings for the practice areas it covers. It does not appear on pages for work it does not do.
- Online advice. Prime Legal Solicitors advises clients remotely, so it can appear first on town pages where it has no office. Its card then says it advises online.
- No rank number. It is never given a rank number. Its position does not mean it has the highest GuideScore.
- No effect on scores. A featured placement never changes any firm's GuideScore, including the featured firm's own.
- No effect on other firms. The firms below it appear in exactly the order they would if there were no featured firm.
- Same review rules. Reviews of the featured firm are collected, checked and published under the same reviews policy as every other firm's.
Where the featured firm appears
- first on listings for the practice areas it covers
- in its own labelled card on the home page
- in a labelled box beside guides about the areas of law it covers, separate from the guide itself
- first, with its label, in lists of similar firms on other firms' profiles
- in a panel on other firms' profiles that offers a callback from Prime Legal Solicitors. The panel says that your details go to Prime Legal Solicitors and not to the firm whose profile you are viewing.
Prime Legal Solicitors is the trading name of Prime Legal Group Ltd, SRA number 834471. If a form on our site passes your details to Prime Legal Solicitors, the form says so before you send it.
Standards we follow
UK consumer law bans paid promotion presented as editorial content unless the payment is made clear. It also bans fake reviews, and reviews that hide that they were paid for or rewarded (Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20). That is why we label featured placements and check every review before it goes live.
The SRA publishes a voluntary code for comparison websites that cover legal services. One of its conditions is that a site is not owned, controlled or managed by a law firm, or by anyone else with a conflict of interest. Because we have a commercial relationship with Prime Legal Solicitors, we do not claim to meet that condition, and we do not take part in the code. We follow its other principles:
- we explain how we rank firms and how we make money
- we label paid placements and disclose our relationship with Prime Legal Solicitors, including the forms that send your details to it
- we take regulatory details from the SRA register and correct mistakes when we find them
- you can compare firms on more than price, including their services, languages, offices and reviews
- the site is free for you to use
- we publish critical reviews as well as positive ones, let reviewers change or remove their own reviews, and let firms reply to or challenge a review
- our privacy policy explains how we use personal data
- we tell you how to complain to us and how long we take to reply
Questions and corrections
If a firm appears in the wrong place, a score looks wrong or a label is missing, email hello@solicitorsguide.co.uk. Firms can also claim their profile to keep their details up to date.